Canterbury Park, Shakopee, Minn logo

Ranking The Derby Winners

by The Oracle

Here’s my personal ranking of the past ten Derby Winners from top to bottom. Where will this year’s winner fit?

1) Barbaro – Best I’ve seen, he effortlessy crushed a very good field. #1 with a bullet and undefeated. Would have loved to see the Barbaro/Bernardini throwdown in the Preakness.
2) Street Sense – Devastating mid-race move he loved Churchill and beat perhaps the best three-yo crop in the past ten years with a crafty ride by Calvin Bo-rail.
3) Smarty Jones – Undefeated Derby winner outran his pedigree over an off-track, won by widening lengths and was 50 yards from retiring undefeated.
4) Big Brown – Visually impressive his physical ailments perhaps prevented the Triple Crown completion. Not a great 3yo crop to beat.
5) Funny Cide – Gritty against Empire Maker and Peace Rules he was the real deal as a 3yo.
6) Fusaichi Pegasus – Speed figs weren’t that inspiring, hard to gauge how good he was.
7) Charismatic – Claimer to Derby winner shocked the world with an authoritative victory at long odds. Near Triple Crown winner, Lukas magic works again.
8) War Emblem – Lone speed peaked at the right time against a mediocre bunch. Two huge months marked entire career.
9) Monarchos – meltdown on the front end and he fired huge against better quality Point Given and Congaree.
10) Giacomo – fast splits and dream trip. Probably 7th or 8th most talented horse in the race.